Chemically complex multicomponent alloys possess exceptional properties derived from an inexhaustible compositional space. The complexity however makes interatomic potential development challenging. We explore two complementary machine-learned potentials---the moment tensor potential (MTP) and the Gaussian moment neural network (GM-NN)---in simultaneously describing configurational and vibrational degrees of freedom in the Ta-V-Cr-W alloy family. Both models are equally accurate with excellent performance evaluated against density-functional-theory. They achieve root-mean-square-errors (RMSEs) in energies of less than a few meV/atom across 0 K ordered and high-temperature disordered configurations included in the training. Even for compositions not in training, relative energy RMSEs at high temperatures are within a few meV/atom. High-temperature molecular dynamics forces have similarly small RMSEs of about 0.15 eV/\AA for the disordered quaternary included in, and ternaries not part of training. MTPs achieve faster convergence with training size; GM-NNs are faster in execution. Active learning is partially beneficial and should be complemented with conventional human-based training set generation.
%0 Journal Article
%1 Gubaev2023
%A Gubaev, Konstantin
%A Zaverkin, Viktor
%A Srinivasan, Prashanth
%A Duff, Andrew Ian
%A Kästner, Johannes
%A Grabowski, Blazej
%D 2023
%J npj Computational Materials
%K EXC2075 PN3 PN3A-4 selected
%N 1
%P 129
%R 10.1038/s41524-023-01073-w
%T Performance of two complementary machine-learned potentials in modelling chemically complex systems
%U https://doi.org/10.1038/s41524-023-01073-w
%V 9
%X Chemically complex multicomponent alloys possess exceptional properties derived from an inexhaustible compositional space. The complexity however makes interatomic potential development challenging. We explore two complementary machine-learned potentials---the moment tensor potential (MTP) and the Gaussian moment neural network (GM-NN)---in simultaneously describing configurational and vibrational degrees of freedom in the Ta-V-Cr-W alloy family. Both models are equally accurate with excellent performance evaluated against density-functional-theory. They achieve root-mean-square-errors (RMSEs) in energies of less than a few meV/atom across 0 K ordered and high-temperature disordered configurations included in the training. Even for compositions not in training, relative energy RMSEs at high temperatures are within a few meV/atom. High-temperature molecular dynamics forces have similarly small RMSEs of about 0.15 eV/\AA for the disordered quaternary included in, and ternaries not part of training. MTPs achieve faster convergence with training size; GM-NNs are faster in execution. Active learning is partially beneficial and should be complemented with conventional human-based training set generation.
@article{Gubaev2023,
abstract = {Chemically complex multicomponent alloys possess exceptional properties derived from an inexhaustible compositional space. The complexity however makes interatomic potential development challenging. We explore two complementary machine-learned potentials---the moment tensor potential (MTP) and the Gaussian moment neural network (GM-NN)---in simultaneously describing configurational and vibrational degrees of freedom in the Ta-V-Cr-W alloy family. Both models are equally accurate with excellent performance evaluated against density-functional-theory. They achieve root-mean-square-errors (RMSEs) in energies of less than a few meV/atom across 0 K ordered and high-temperature disordered configurations included in the training. Even for compositions not in training, relative energy RMSEs at high temperatures are within a few meV/atom. High-temperature molecular dynamics forces have similarly small RMSEs of about 0.15 eV/{\AA} for the disordered quaternary included in, and ternaries not part of training. MTPs achieve faster convergence with training size; GM-NNs are faster in execution. Active learning is partially beneficial and should be complemented with conventional human-based training set generation.},
added-at = {2025-02-14T11:17:09.000+0100},
author = {Gubaev, Konstantin and Zaverkin, Viktor and Srinivasan, Prashanth and Duff, Andrew Ian and K{\"a}stner, Johannes and Grabowski, Blazej},
biburl = {https://puma.ub.uni-stuttgart.de/bibtex/2012abfee1a3b3d63508bb45b51639816/simtechpuma},
day = 25,
doi = {10.1038/s41524-023-01073-w},
interhash = {77490c81feaefdacd3f9a22e021dcbd6},
intrahash = {012abfee1a3b3d63508bb45b51639816},
issn = {2057-3960},
journal = {npj Computational Materials},
keywords = {EXC2075 PN3 PN3A-4 selected},
month = {07},
number = 1,
pages = 129,
timestamp = {2025-02-14T11:17:09.000+0100},
title = {Performance of two complementary machine-learned potentials in modelling chemically complex systems},
url = {https://doi.org/10.1038/s41524-023-01073-w},
volume = 9,
year = 2023
}